Score: 9

"Better Than The First One"

submission: One Ring to Rule ThemAll2

date: October 24, 2004

I liked this one more than the first. It just seemed better. Oh, I don't think that too many people will get the Nemoy joke. I did, though.

Score: 6

"Could Be Tons Better"

submission: One Ring to Rule Them All

date: October 24, 2004

At least there is a special edition.....besides that, the original isn't that good.

Score: 9

"Better Than The Regular One"

submission: One Ring: Special Edition

date: October 24, 2004

This is an OK movie. But, the special edition made it better.